top of page
Search

Why the No Surprises Act Changed OON Claims

drdanabrems41
6 days ago
8 min read

Updated: 5 days ago


Stethoscope resting on a calculator, representing out-of-network claim payment calculations under the No Surprises Act

For years, out-of-network billing followed a fairly predictable pattern. A patient saw a provider who did not participate with their plan, the plan paid what it chose to pay, and the provider billed the patient for the rest. Practices built entire collection strategies around that balance. The No Surprises Act changed that pattern for a large group of services, and many practices are still adjusting their workflows several years after the law took effect. For organizations that rely on Out of Network Billing as part of their revenue strategy, the law did not end out-of-network reimbursement, but it did change who pays, how payment is negotiated, and what the patient can be asked to cover. This article explains what changed, which claims are affected, and how practices can protect revenue under the new rules.

What the No Surprises Act Was Designed to Fix

The No Surprises Act took effect on January 1, 2022. Its main goal was to protect patients from unexpected bills in situations where they had little or no control over who treated them. Before the law, a patient could choose an in-network hospital for surgery and still receive a large bill from an out-of-network anesthesiologist, radiologist, or assistant surgeon they never chose. Emergency patients faced the same problem when they were taken to the nearest facility.

The law addresses those situations in three main areas:

  • Emergency services provided by out-of-network facilities and providers.

  • Non-emergency services provided by out-of-network providers at in-network facilities, such as hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers.

  • Air ambulance services from out-of-network providers.

Ground ambulance services were not included in the federal protections, although some states have their own rules.

How Patient Cost-Sharing Changed

The most visible change for practices is what they can collect from the patient. For services protected by the law, the patient's cost-sharing is limited to what they would pay if the provider were in network. That cost-sharing also counts toward the patient's in-network deductible and out-of-pocket maximum.

In practical terms, this means a provider generally cannot balance bill the patient for the difference between the billed charge and the plan's payment on protected claims. Any remaining dispute about the amount is between the provider and the health plan, not the patient.

The notice and consent exception

For certain non-emergency services, an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility can ask the patient to waive these protections through a formal notice and consent process. The notice must be given in advance, generally at least 72 hours before the scheduled service, or at least three hours in advance when the appointment is made on the same day.

This exception does not apply to everything. Ancillary services, such as emergency medicine, anesthesiology, pathology, radiology, neonatology, assistant surgeon services, hospitalist and intensivist services, and diagnostic services including lab work, cannot use notice and consent. It also cannot be used when there is no in-network provider available at the facility, or for unforeseen urgent needs that arise during a procedure.

The New Payment Process for Out-of-Network Claims

Because patients are taken out of the middle, the law created a structured process for providers and plans to settle payment.

Step 1: Initial payment or denial

After receiving a clean claim for a protected service, the plan has 30 calendar days to send an initial payment or a notice of denial. The plan's payment is often tied to the qualifying payment amount (QPA), which is generally based on the plan's median contracted rate for the same service in the same geographic area.

Step 2: Open negotiation

If the provider disagrees with the payment, either party can start a 30-business-day open negotiation period. This is a formal window to try to reach an agreement before moving to arbitration. Many disputes settle here, especially when the provider brings clear supporting information.

Step 3: Independent dispute resolution

If negotiation fails, either party can start the federal independent dispute resolution (IDR) process within four business days after the negotiation period ends. A certified IDR entity reviews offers from both sides and selects one. Both parties pay administrative fees, and the non-prevailing party typically pays the IDR entity fee.

The rules governing how IDR entities weigh the QPA and other factors have been shaped by litigation since the law took effect, and operational details have changed more than once. Practices should rely on current federal guidance rather than older summaries. The CMS No Surprises Act resource center is the most direct place to check for updated rules, fact sheets, and IDR operational guidance.

Where State Law Fits In

Several states had surprise billing laws before the federal act, and some still apply. In general, when a state has a specified law that sets payment for a particular plan and service, that state process may apply instead of the federal IDR process. This is most common for fully insured plans regulated by the state.

Self-funded employer plans governed by ERISA generally fall under the federal process unless a state has opted in through an arrangement that allows its law to apply. This creates a practical challenge: two patients with similar services can follow different payment paths depending on how their plan is funded and where it is regulated.

Practices need a way to identify plan type early, ideally during eligibility verification, so they know which rules apply before the claim ever goes out.

What Changed for Uninsured and Self-Pay Patients

The law also added protections for patients who are uninsured or choose not to use insurance. Providers and facilities must give these patients a good faith estimate of expected charges for scheduled services, and on request.

If the final bill is substantially higher than the estimate, generally $400 or more above it, the patient may be able to use the patient-provider dispute resolution process. That makes accurate estimates more than a courtesy. They are now part of the practice's compliance responsibility.

Good faith estimate best practices

  • Use a standard template that lists expected services, codes, and charges.

  • Include services from co-providers and co-facilities where required.

  • Give estimates within the required timeframes based on when the service is scheduled.

  • Keep a copy of every estimate with the patient record.

Specialties That Feel the Change Most

Not every practice is affected equally. Specialties that frequently treat patients at in-network facilities without being chosen by the patient carry most of the impact. Anesthesiology, emergency medicine, radiology, pathology, and neonatology groups historically relied on out-of-network payments in some markets, and those are exactly the services where notice and consent is not available.

Surgical specialties feel the change in a different way. Assistant surgeons fall under the ancillary category, so a practice that sends an out-of-network assistant to an in-network hospital generally cannot shift the balance to the patient. Primary surgeons performing scheduled, non-emergency procedures may have more flexibility through notice and consent, but only when the process is followed carefully and the patient truly has a choice.

Behavioral health, physical therapy, and other office-based specialties that see patients out of network in their own clinics are often less affected, because the federal protections focus on emergency care, facility-based care, and air ambulance services. Even so, these practices still need to follow good faith estimate rules for uninsured and self-pay patients.

Common Mistakes Practices Make Under the No Surprises Act

Balance billing protected claims

Sending a balance bill on a protected claim is one of the most serious errors, both from a compliance and patient relations standpoint. Billing systems should flag claims for protected services so statements are held until the plan's payment and the patient's correct cost-sharing are confirmed.

Missing the negotiation and IDR deadlines

The 30-business-day negotiation window and the four-business-day IDR initiation deadline are short. Practices that do not track remittance dates closely often lose the right to dispute a low payment. A simple deadline tracker tied to each out-of-network remittance can prevent this.

Using notice and consent where it is not allowed

Some practices assume a signed consent form solves everything. If the service falls into an ancillary category, or the form was not delivered within the required timeframe, the consent may not be valid. That leaves the practice exposed if it balance bills.

Weak documentation for IDR

When a dispute goes to IDR, the provider's offer is only as strong as the information supporting it. Practices that cannot show the complexity of the case, the provider's training and experience, or prior contracted rates with the plan are at a disadvantage.

Ignoring plan type

Without knowing whether a plan is fully insured, self-funded, or subject to a state law, a practice cannot choose the right dispute path. Collecting this information during verification saves time later.

Building a Workflow That Works

Practices that handle out-of-network claims well under the No Surprises Act usually have a defined process from scheduling through final payment:

  1. Scheduling and verification: Confirm network status, plan type, and whether the service is likely to be protected.

  2. Patient communication: Provide notice and consent only where permitted, and provide good faith estimates for self-pay patients.

  3. Claim submission: Submit clean claims promptly with complete documentation.

  4. Remittance review: Compare the plan's payment to expected value and flag low payments right away.

  5. Negotiation: Start open negotiation within the allowed window when payment is inadequate.

  6. IDR decision: Decide whether the disputed amount justifies IDR fees and prepare a strong offer if it does.

  7. Patient billing: Bill only the correct in-network cost-sharing for protected claims.

Teams that work with a partner like Dr Biller RCM often centralize these steps so that deadlines, payer responses, and IDR outcomes are tracked in one place rather than scattered across inboxes and spreadsheets.

Measuring results

Track a few key numbers each month: the share of out-of-network claims that are protected, average initial payment compared to billed charges, the number of claims taken to negotiation, settlement rates, and IDR outcomes. Over time, these numbers show whether the process is improving or whether certain payers consistently underpay.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the No Surprises Act apply to Medicare and Medicaid patients?

The law's surprise billing protections mainly apply to group health plans and individual health insurance coverage. Medicare and Medicaid already have their own rules that limit balance billing, so those programs follow separate requirements.

Can a provider still bill a patient for out-of-network care?

Yes, in some situations. If the service is not protected, or if valid notice and consent was obtained for an eligible non-emergency service, the provider may bill according to the patient's out-of-network benefits. For protected services, the patient pays only in-network cost-sharing.

How long does a plan have to pay an out-of-network claim?

For protected services, the plan must send an initial payment or a notice of denial within 30 calendar days of receiving a clean claim. If the provider disagrees, either party can start the open negotiation period.

What is the qualifying payment amount?

The QPA is generally the plan's median contracted rate for the same or similar service in the same geographic area. It is used to calculate patient cost-sharing and is one of the factors considered in the IDR process.

Is it worth taking every low payment to IDR?

Not always. IDR involves fees and staff time, so practices usually reserve it for claims where the difference is large enough to justify the cost, or where batching similar claims makes the process more efficient.

Looking Ahead

The No Surprises Act changed out-of-network billing from a patient collection problem into a payer negotiation process. Practices that adapted by tightening verification, respecting patient protections, tracking deadlines, and building strong documentation for disputes have been able to protect much of their revenue. Practices that kept their old workflows often found themselves stuck with low initial payments and missed dispute windows. Because federal guidance and court decisions continue to shape how the law works, regular review of current rules is part of the job now. If your practice needs help managing out-of-network claims, negotiations, and IDR, working with experienced Medical billing services can help you stay compliant while recovering the reimbursement your providers have earned.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page